• Subscribe
  • Magazines
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Sunday 1 June 2025
  • zh-hant 中文
  • ja 日本語
  • en English
IAG
Advertisement
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Cambodia
    • China
    • CNMI
    • Europe
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Japan
    • Laos
    • Latin America
    • Malaysia
    • Macau
    • Nepal
    • New Zealand
    • North America
    • North Korea
    • Philippines
    • Russia
    • Singapore
    • South Korea
    • Sri Lanka
    • Thailand
    • UAE
    • Vietnam
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
  • 日本語
No Result
View All Result
IAG
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Cambodia
    • China
    • CNMI
    • Europe
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Japan
    • Laos
    • Latin America
    • Malaysia
    • Macau
    • Nepal
    • New Zealand
    • North America
    • North Korea
    • Philippines
    • Russia
    • Singapore
    • South Korea
    • Sri Lanka
    • Thailand
    • UAE
    • Vietnam
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
  • 日本語
No Result
View All Result
IAG
No Result
View All Result

SPECIAL REPORT: Oshidori claims “corruption” in Nagasaki RFP while NIKI suggests legal action after “very troubling” process

Andrew W Scott and Shintaro Kamimura by Andrew W Scott and Shintaro Kamimura
Fri 27 Aug 2021 at 05:40
Huis Ten Bosch

Huis Ten Bosch in Nagasaki was the planned site for an IR.

60
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In the wake of Nagasaki Prefecture’s defense of its RFP process for an integrated resort at Huis Ten Bosch at Sasebo City, further shocking details have emerged relating to Nagasaki’s treatment of the two bidders not chosen by the Prefecture, Oshidori International Development and NIKI Chyau Fwu (Parkview) Group.

Both Oshidori and NIKI have publicly stated they were told by Nagasaki Prefecture there were “probity issues” in relation to their bids, but Nagasaki Prefecture not only refused to reveal to the bidders what those issues were, but even the identity of the outsourced company which Nagasaki Prefecture hired to conduct the probity investigations. Both bidders claim Nagasaki Prefecture “suggested” they withdraw their bids, otherwise the alleged probity issues would be made public.

OSHIDORI
Speaking directly to IAG, an Oshidori spokesman said, “The Nagasaki Prefecture has no other option at this point than to lie to cover up its corruption. We just feel bad for the people of Nagasaki because they deserve a better IR and a better government.

“The Nagasaki Prefecture threatened us, saying that if we don’t want their [probity] investigation report to become public we better withdraw [from the entire RFP process] before our [final] presentation in front of the judges.”

Oshidori refused to withdraw and participated in the final presentation before the judging panel, which took place on 4 August 2021.

Two days later, Oshidori issued a press release dramatically withdrawing from the process, but some have interpreted the press release as not actually a withdrawal and merely a threat to withdraw, given the press release stated that Oshidori “[is withdrawing] unless there are certain changes to the developmental and operational rules imposed by the Nagasaki Prefecture, and unless the RFP process is conducted in an ethical manner.”

It seems Nagasaki took this view, acting as though Oshidori had not withdrawn by awarding them a score of 682.8 points in the announcement of the winner of the RFP process. This placed Oshidori in second place behind eventual winner Casinos Austria International with 697.0 points, with third placed NIKI Parkview bringing up the rear with 667.1 points.

When asked by IAG for any evidence of their claim that they were threatened by Nagasaki, the Oshidori spokesman said, “We have correspondence between our [legal] counsel and the Prefecture, but the correspondence is covered by an NDA.”

Oshidori claims that Nagasaki refuses to release the alleged “negative information” (even to Oshidori itself) for “confidentiality” reasons but the Oshidori spokesman said, “We would agree to waive our right to privacy so that the people of Nagasaki can see the charade being perpetrated by the Prefecture.”

NIKI PARKVIEW
IAG has seen minutes of two meetings between NIKI and Nagasaki Prefecture representatives held on 12 and 27 July, just weeks before the final presentation on 4 August. When IAG approached NIKI to confirm the veracity of the minutes, NIKI confirmed that the minutes were indeed genuine.

The minutes provide for fascinating reading. They confirm that Nagasaki Prefecture asserted to NIKI they were in possession of “negative probity information” relating to their group and Nagasaki gave NIKI three options to deal with the issue. Firstly, NIKI could try to answer the information and dispel the claims, in which case the RFP process would continue as usual. Secondly, if the claims could not be dispelled to Nagasaki’s satisfaction, they would be made public. And thirdly, it was suggested to NIKI if they were to withdraw from the RFP process by 30 July then Nagasaki would simply announce the withdrawal without any reference to the probity investigation.

NIKI attempted to dispel any claims by providing Nagasaki with a host of information relating to their consortium, which Nagasaki shared with the probity investigation company, but the minutes of the 27 July meeting confirm the result of the probity check was unchanged. This left NIKI with only the final two options – either withdraw from the RFP process or see the alleged negative probity information made public.

In the minutes of the 27 July meeting, a Nagasaki Prefecture official appears to validate NIKI’s claim, stating, “… if you withdraw by 30 July, we will not announce that you were not selected due to the results of the integrity survey [another term for “probity investigation”] … but if you do not, we will announce it in the final announcement, we will announce we could not select [NIKI] as a result of the integrity investigation.”

The meetings were attended by NIKI and several professionals and officials representing NIKI, including Dr Ku Shin, Chairman and CEO of NIKI. Between them, those on the NIKI side of the meeting made a slew of comments highly critical of Nagasaki’s RFP process, including the following, which are reproduced from the minutes verbatim:

“[in relation to the ‘negative probity information’] we have been told the jurisdiction [has used an investigation] consultant that refuses to identify themselves, refuses to give their credentials, refuses to give the basis for which they reject [NIKI] … you are so far below any standard of any gaming entity in the world. It is beyond belief!”

“This process … has no transparency and is clearly sub-standard, with a threat … to make a public statement to embarrass us and damage our reputation …”

“We do not believe [the Nagasaki RFP] process … has been … either fair or adequate.”

“I do not believe Nagasaki can [apply] its responsibility by hiring someone who is either incompetent or corrupt.”

“… legitimate [industry] investigators do not try to hide in the dark!”

“… we had hoped to bring a world leading IR to [Nagasaki] … so this is profoundly disappointing … we have limited choice but to go back, and speak with our counsel to try to determine what our legal rights are going forward …”

RelatedPosts

Japan’s Dynam reopens 101 pachinko halls after some closure requests lifted

Dynam Japan continues pachinko hall rationalization as revenues fall again in FY25

Tue 27 May 2025 at 06:45
Two-day Japan IR Online Forum to start today

Japanese said to have gambled US$45 billion on illegal overseas betting sites in 2024

Fri 23 May 2025 at 05:51
Okada Manila recognizes Earth Hour with eco-friendly initiatives

Japan’s Universal falls to US$52 million loss in 1Q25, outlines plan to promote new online gaming platform at Okada Manila

Thu 15 May 2025 at 05:56
Sega Sammy’s FY25 sales hit by decline in pachinko but new gaming segment shows promise

Sega Sammy’s FY25 sales hit by decline in pachinko but new gaming segment shows promise

Tue 13 May 2025 at 05:54
Load More

“You refused to provide any information in what is [a] very troubling process … I object to this process in its entirety!”

“We have the right to know as we paid JPY 11 million for the investigation.”

“Did the prefecture conduct due diligence and an integrity investigation of the [investigation] company?”

It was even hinted that perhaps there was a darker cause, with one official connected to the NIKI bid stating, “… is something going on there with different motivation?”

And finally, in a suggestion of what may be yet to come, Dr Ku ended the 27 July meeting stating, “… let’s have legal action …”

IAG understands NIKI presented a request to the Prefectural IR Promotion Council and the Governor of Nagasaki on 29 July, which included complaints about the probity investigation, questions about the integrity of the investigation company and the advisors Nagasaki Prefecture hired, and a statement that if Nagasaki does not provide “sincere answers”, then “next steps” will be taken.

There has been some suggestion that Oshidori and NIKI are seeking a “redo” of the process, but given the current angst, it remains to be seen whether either party, or any other party, would want to engage in an IR bid in Nagasaki. The prevailing animosity means any “redo” process would certainly need to be conducted by a party that was not only beyond reproach, scrupulous and completely independent, but also seen to be so.

___________

LEGAL NOTE: The opinions and statements in this article are as directly quoted from Oshidori International Development and from written minutes of meetings attended by NIKI Chyau Fwu (Parkview) Group and seen by IAG. They do not necessarily represent the opinions or views of IAG Japan or Inside Asian Gaming.

Tags: corruptionirJapanNagasakiNIKI Chyau Fwu (Parkview) GroupOshidori International Developmentprobitysasebo city
Share24Share4
Andrew W Scott and Shintaro Kamimura

Andrew W Scott and Shintaro Kamimura

Born in Australia, Andrew is a gaming industry expert and media publisher, commentator and journalist who moved to Hong Kong in 2005 and then Macau in 2009, when he founded O MEDIA, one of Macau’s largest media companies and parent company of Inside Asian Gaming.

Shintaro Kamimura (from Tokyo) has worked for many years as a professional mahjong player, mahjong instructor and a writer. He travels far and wide both in Japan and overseas, fine-tuning his already extensive expertise in many areas of gaming, including Japanese pachinko and slot machines, and overseas casinos.

Current Issue

Editorial – Foreigner-only casinos: Seize the day

Editorial – Foreigner-only casinos: Seize the day

by Ben Blaschke
Thu 29 May 2025 at 13:38

I was recently asked by someone working at a foreigner-only casino for my thoughts on the outlook for the Asian...

On the brink

On the brink

by Pierce Chan
Thu 29 May 2025 at 13:27

The transition period for Macau’s 11 satellite casinos is set to expire at the end of this year, after which...

A moral defense of gambling

A moral defense of gambling

by Andrew Russell
Wed 28 May 2025 at 18:19

Economist Andrew Russell explores the differences between community benefit and in-principle arguments for the existence of a legal gambling industry...

Face to face

Face to face

by Ben Blaschke
Wed 28 May 2025 at 18:08

Konami caught the eye at the recent G2E Asia show in Macau with its SYNK Vision Tables, which utilize facial...

Evolution Asia
Aristocrat
GLI
Mindslot
Mindslot
Solaire
Hann
Tecnet
Nustar
Jumbo

Related Posts

10 Years Ago – Reimagining Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka gazettes draft bill to establish Gambling Regulatory Authority

by Newsdesk
Sat 31 May 2025 at 06:03

A draft bill that would establish an official regulator for the Sri Lankan gaming industry, to be known as the Gambling Regulatory Authority, has taken another step forward after being gazetted. According to the Sri Lanka Mirror, the official announcement...

RGB International signs agreement to distribute KL Saberi and Atlas gaming machines

After record-breaking sales in 2024, Malaysia’s RGB sees 1Q25 profit fall to

by Newsdesk
Sat 31 May 2025 at 05:53

Malaysian gaming product distributor RGB International Bhd has reported group-wide revenue of MYR73.6 million (US$17.3 million) for the three months to 31 March 2025, down 65% year-on-year due to a lower number of products sold. The figure was also 79%...

Robert Goldstein to step aside as LVS Chairman and CEO from March 2026, replaced by Patrick Dumont

Robert Goldstein: Macau gaming market challenged by increased competition, online gambling and US-Sino trade war

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 30 May 2025 at 06:42

Las Vegas Sands (LVS) Chairman and CEO Robert Goldstein has bemoaned the lingering impact of the US-China trade war, as well as increased domestic and regional competition and the rise of online gambling across Asia for sustained flatness in the...

Industry hopes Thai Entertainment Complex Roundtable can establish “common ground” with those opposing legal casinos

Industry hopes Thai Entertainment Complex Roundtable can establish “common ground” with those opposing legal casinos

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 30 May 2025 at 05:38

Industry figures taking part in the Thai Entertainment Complex Roundtable (TECR) next Thursday 5 June hope to find common ground with those who oppose Thailand’s Entertainment Complex Bill, citing the opportunity to use an evidence-based approach to achieve outcomes that...



IAG

© 2005-2024
Inside Asian Gaming.
All rights reserved.

  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
  • NEWSFEED
  • MAG ARTICLES
  • VIDEO
  • OPINION
  • TAGS
  • REGIONAL
  • EVENTS
  • CONSULTING
  • CONTRIBUTORS
  • MAGAZINES
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISE
  • 日本語

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • 日本語
  • Subscribe
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • Magazines
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • About
  • Home for G2E Asia

© 2005-2024
Inside Asian Gaming.
All rights reserved.

  • English
  • 日本語