• Subscribe
  • Magazines
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Saturday 5 July 2025
  • zh-hant 中文
  • ja 日本語
  • en English
IAG
Advertisement
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Cambodia
    • China
    • CNMI
    • Europe
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Japan
    • Laos
    • Latin America
    • Malaysia
    • Macau
    • Nepal
    • New Zealand
    • North America
    • North Korea
    • Philippines
    • Russia
    • Singapore
    • South Korea
    • Sri Lanka
    • Thailand
    • UAE
    • Vietnam
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
No Result
View All Result
IAG
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Cambodia
    • China
    • CNMI
    • Europe
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Japan
    • Laos
    • Latin America
    • Malaysia
    • Macau
    • Nepal
    • New Zealand
    • North America
    • North Korea
    • Philippines
    • Russia
    • Singapore
    • South Korea
    • Sri Lanka
    • Thailand
    • UAE
    • Vietnam
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
No Result
View All Result
IAG
No Result
View All Result

(Mis)calculating social costs and consequences of Japan’s IR development

Newsdesk by Newsdesk
Thu 8 Jun 2017 at 03:39
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In the penultimate instalment of their five part series on the development of Japanese integrated resorts, casino and integrated resort experts Dr Glenn McCartney and Dr Andy Nazarechuk discuss the divisive issue of problem gambling.

By Dr Glenn McCartney and Dr Andy Nazarechuk

The mere mention of the word “casino” still raises eyebrows with perhaps greater levels of interest compared to other forms of gambling such as lotteries, lucky draws, sports betting or gambling packaged to assist a cause or within an entertainment parlor. A list of vices or undesirable activities will often be cited by opposition groups as a consequence of bringing a casino into the neighbourhood.

What is important in Japan, given the stakes, is that the issues be addressed with science and empirical based evidence void of emotions or perceptions. As a starting point, what are the social costs and consequences directly brought about by gambling? And having defined these, how do you measure social costs and prove that economic consequences were brought about specifically by the presence of adding an IR to any Japanese city?

These are important fundamental, initial questions in the great social cost debate, which unfortunately is largely confused, poorly calculated and for the most part fraught with inaccuracies.

For some, the issue of whether they determine gambling to be “good” or “bad” (such as some might see smoking, drugs and alcohol) will determine their emphasis and response bias. The consequences listed from problem gambling behavior often include theft, corruption, bankruptcy and other illegal activities. But let’s consider that a pathological gambler may have compulsive disorder issues (shopping, smoking and alcohol) or gamble due to other problems. Should the casino then be blamed and aligned with all the social costs brought about by this individual? Was the casino the primary reason for a crime being committed, for company bankruptcy or for a sudden increase in divorce rates?

There is great debate on the subject, but given the attention granted the issue now in regards to Japanese IRs, a rational and empirical based approach is needed. We need to refer to the science.

On social costs related to gambling, Walker and Barnett in 1999* produced considerable detail, science and debate on what is and isn’t, in their opinion, a social cost of gambling. They present several interesting scenarios. Before addiction, they argue, the person makes a decision to gamble rationally. The addiction may lead to a decline in quality of life and regret towards the original decision. The argument is that since the consequences experienced by the gambler were made based on rational actions, these are not social costs.

The Macau government consumes a large part of its time and resources on taxing, monitoring and policing the casino industry. The Macau labour department constantly deals with large quantities of work permit requests; the public works department is frequently reviewing multiple casino resort construction permits while the tourism department spends resources licensing and inspecting restaurants and bars.

An argument is that this diverts government resources from welfare, education, tourism and city infrastructure developments. Therefore, this could be considered a social cost. Japanese authorities will similarly need to avert attention and resources to new IR construction, development and policy in their daily operations (which includes those concerning social issues), as well as ramping up their capacities and capabilities so as other departments do not forget other priorities.

Recent reports have put problem gambler numbers in Japan at five million. In jurisdictions with legal and well-run casinos there is a legitimate opportunity to provide counselling, support and educational resources to the community. There are dozens of methods employed globally to communicate and try to prevent problem gambling. In jurisdictions with strong regulatory policies concerning problem gambling, casinos can be required to train their staff to identify problem gamblers. Materials with resources and counselling information must be provided where all players can see it.

 

Macau’s government spends considerable time and resources monitoring and policing the city’s casino industry

Studies have shown that the percentage of players cited as problem gamblers can be anywhere from 1% to 6%. The number can be lower if cited by those supportive and higher if cited by those against casino introduction or expansion. Naturally there is the issue of protecting the vulnerable, the young and the elderly as well as casino staff who spend large quantities of their time around the casino environment.

There are many factors to consider that should be part of a community assessment on preventing gambling addiction. They include the background of casino operators and suppliers in addressing responsible gaming; size of the casino (tables, slots, pachinko machines); opening hours (24/7); whether the location is integrated into the city network, is in an isolated location or a cluster permitting spill-over to more than one casino property visit; casino credit policy; regulation and regulation committee; casino staff training; and table limits.

Casinos can implement policies such as putting their ATMs external to the casino floor with daily maximum withdrawal limits, the logic being a gambler will have time to reflect as he or she walks to the ATM. The current debate on smoking on Macau’s casino floors and a smoking lounge compromise could mean that gamblers spend less time away from the tables to smoke.

One of the most discussed and interesting methods of controlling access to the casino is through an entrance levy such as the one in place in Singapore. The entrance levy is misunderstood by many who think that the primary purpose of the levy is to prevent problem gamblers from entering the casino. This is simply not the case.

The entrance levy provides three main functions. First, it requires each person who enters the casino to identify his or herself with a passport or ID card. This provides a database for use with exclusion programs. Foreigners enter free, while locals pay S$100 to enter, or they can pay S$2000 for one year’s access. The entrance levy generates S$150 million dollars or more per year to government revenues to spend on community programs.

Second, the entrance levy makes it difficult for people with lower incomes to gain access to the casino. The levy forces low income earners to think twice before entering a casino. This in itself reduces the number of people who may try a casino or become problem gamblers. Finally, the revenue generated from the entrance levy is not dedicated to solving problem gambling issues, but is given to a local government-approved agency whose main purpose is to fund community activities and services. This allows the local community to see actual benefits that are derived directly from the casino. The casino benefits from those who gamble, the government benefits from increased tax revenue and the community benefits from the casino entrance levy. It is a win-win-win for all concerned.

RelatedPosts

Macau planning to ban all forms of advertising for gambling activities

Macau planning to ban all forms of advertising for gambling activities

Fri 4 Jul 2025 at 15:04
Wynn Al Marjan Island releases first renderings of uber-luxury Enclave suite and apartment offering

Wynn Al Marjan Island releases first renderings of uber-luxury Enclave suite and apartment offering

Fri 4 Jul 2025 at 05:59
The 2024 Asian Gaming Power 50

Bally’s ready to pull out of Star rescue deal if AUSTRAC issues monster fine

Fri 4 Jul 2025 at 05:37
Grand Korea Leisure books US$11.4 million profit in 1Q25 on higher casino sales, better margins

Grand Korea Leisure reports sequential gain but year-on-year decline in casino revenue to US$25.5 million

Fri 4 Jul 2025 at 04:52
Load More

Casino exclusion programmes are also popular. A gambler can self-exclude him or herself from a casino if he or she believes they have a problem. Often a member of their immediate family can also ask the gambler to be excluded. The Macau government extends this exclusion to the public sector apart from those tasked to monitor and police the casino. Kangwon Land is the only casino in South Korea where locals are allowed to gamble, but those living in the local vicinity face additional restrictions on the number of visits per month. Key, however, is monitoring and enforcement. Singapore and Korea requires the presentation of ID cards to gain access. Macau and the Philippines do not, the weakness in their process being that it may be more difficult to identify a problem gambler who has been excluded.

Gambling has been around for a long time and will continue to be a part of the world we live in. In the US, prior to 1978, the only place to legally gamble in a casino was in Las Vegas. Common perception was that if casinos were allowed to open elsewhere, there would be more people with gambling problems. Today, there are casinos in 48 of the 50 states.

Casino tourism, like any form of tourism, is a double-edged sword. The cost-benefit argument should always be implemented with a realistic and unbiased assessment. The high revenue stakes and returns on casino development from investor to governmental agencies and NGOs has unfortunately meant conflicting and skewed assessments.

While still a relatively small percentage, those with a gambling problem need and must have assistance to overcome it and regain their normal lives. Strong regulatory policies and a rigorous policy framework will be important for Japan as it is for any casino jurisdiction globally.

We close with an insight from Macau. In the original Lisboa casino, years before the new casino boom, there was a small sign on a column located at the entrance of the casino. It read, “No one can win all the time, we advise you to play merely for pleasure and risk only what you can spare.” Although the sign is gone, that advice still holds true today

Share4Share1
Newsdesk

Newsdesk

Current Issue

Editorial – An inconvenient truth

Editorial – An inconvenient truth

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 15:21

It’s understandable that political observers, academics and members of the public in greenfield jurisdictions would express caution around the legalization...

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 15:19

Siobhan Lane, Light & Wonder’s highly experienced CEO of Gaming, speaks to Inside Asian Gaming about the company’s ongoing transformation...

Honesty is the best policy

Honesty is the best policy

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 14:13

The Thailand Entertainment Complex Roundtable brought industry stakeholders, politicians and supporters of the government’s Entertainment Complex Bill face to face...

Sri Lanka’s casino industry

Sri Lanka’s casino industry

by Shaun McCamley
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 13:36

Industry veteran Shaun McCamley delves into the complex history of Sri Lanka’s casino industry at a time when the country...

Evolution Asia
Your browser does not support HTML5 video.
Aristocrat
GLI
Nustar
SABA
Mindslot
Solaire
Hann
Tecnet
NWR
Jumbo
568Win

Related Posts

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 15:19

Siobhan Lane, Light & Wonder’s highly experienced CEO of Gaming, speaks to Inside Asian Gaming about the company’s ongoing transformation into a content powerhouse and reveals where Asia fits into the journey. Ben Blaschke: Thanks for speaking with IAG, Siobhan....

Behind the curtain

Behind the curtain

by Newsdesk
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 12:40

Hospitality logistics firm BCI Worldwide has firmly established its presence in Macau, playing a part in some of the city’s most iconic integrated resort development projects. Macau, the “Las Vegas of Asia”, is a city synonymous with opulent resorts, world-class...

Of fortune or misfortune

Of fortune or misfortune

by Pierce Chan
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 12:32

At the beginning of June, the Macau government announced that all 11 of the city’s satellite casinos would be shut down this year. The sudden news shocked the community and has led many to question whether the complete closure of...

10 years ago – Tricky balance

10 years ago – Tricky balance

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 12:17

In this regular feature in IAG to celebrate 20 years covering the Asian gaming and leisure industry, we look back at our cover story from exactly 10 years ago, “Tricky balance”, to rediscover what was making the news in July...



IAG

© 2005-2024
Inside Asian Gaming.
All rights reserved.

  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
  • NEWSFEED
  • MAG ARTICLES
  • VIDEO
  • OPINION
  • TAGS
  • REGIONAL
  • EVENTS
  • CONSULTING
  • CONTRIBUTORS
  • MAGAZINES
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISE

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • Magazines
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • About
  • Home for G2E Asia

© 2005-2024
Inside Asian Gaming.
All rights reserved.

  • English