• Subscribe
  • Magazines
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Saturday 5 July 2025
  • zh-hant 中文
  • ja 日本語
  • en English
IAG
Advertisement
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Cambodia
    • China
    • CNMI
    • Europe
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Japan
    • Laos
    • Latin America
    • Malaysia
    • Macau
    • Nepal
    • New Zealand
    • North America
    • North Korea
    • Philippines
    • Russia
    • Singapore
    • South Korea
    • Sri Lanka
    • Thailand
    • UAE
    • Vietnam
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
No Result
View All Result
IAG
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Cambodia
    • China
    • CNMI
    • Europe
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Japan
    • Laos
    • Latin America
    • Malaysia
    • Macau
    • Nepal
    • New Zealand
    • North America
    • North Korea
    • Philippines
    • Russia
    • Singapore
    • South Korea
    • Sri Lanka
    • Thailand
    • UAE
    • Vietnam
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
No Result
View All Result
IAG
No Result
View All Result

Thin End of the Wedge?

Newsdesk by Newsdesk
Wed 1 Jun 2011 at 06:56
1
SHARES
29
VIEWS
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Pansy Ho’s ‘non-compete’ deal with MGM Resorts has some scratching their heads; and others holding their noses

Is MGM Resorts International’s ‘non-compete’ agreement with Pansy Ho compatible with Macau’s legal framework for its gaming industry?

If ‘yes’, what if anything will the agreement do to the competition landscape in Macau? If ‘no’, what is the Macau government going to do about the deal?

The non-compete deal has come about because it looks as though for the first time ever, an individual—Ms Ho—will be allowed to be a shareholder and director of two supposedly competing companies in the Macau gaming market—MGM China Holdings and her father Stanley Ho’s former investment holding company STDM, the parent of SJM Holdings. Even Dr Ho never managed a feat like that in his long career.

The reason it is being allowed now looks due in part to Dr Ho’s fragile health and the succession battle that this parked among his surviving consorts and children for control of STDM and SJM. The Macau government seems to think letting Pansy Ho have some control over MGM China and STDM simultaneously is a lesser evil than having a chaotic succession at STDM/SJM. The latter companies are, after all, essentially proxies for maintaining Chinese control over a burgeoning gaming market with major foreign participants in it.

It took two months of bitter in-fighting among Dr Ho’s surviving consorts and children to arrive at a compromise deal whereby Ms Ho becomes a director of STDM and Dr Ho’s fourth consort Angela Leong gets to run SJM for at least the next six years. No one in power in Macau seems to want to throw all that away on a nicety such as worrying about anti-competitive behaviour issues involving STDM/SJM and MGM China.

Ms Ho said recently at a Hong Kong press conference—supposedly to discuss the initial public offering for MGM China Holdings, her joint gaming venture in Macau with MGM Resorts—that she wanted to be an ‘MVP’ (most valuable player). She didn’t say she wanted to play every position on the field, which is how the twin track approach of directing MGM China and STDM looks to some observers.

In theory, anti-competitive practices are illegal in Macau. Article 21, paragraph 3, of Macau Law 16/2001 states: “Any form of arrangement amongst concession companies or associated companies of a concession company which may obstruct, restrict, impair or destroy fair competition shall be prohibited”.

The clause was inserted in that particular law—a statute setting out the framework for the Macau gaming industry after market liberalisation—because Macau did not have (and still does not have) a law dealing with restrictive trade practices. Whether Article 21, paragraph 3 will ever be enforced is another matter.

MGM Resorts is to some extent stuck in the middle of the STDM succession drama—an issue not of its making. MGM Resorts would much rather have Ms Ho on board at MGM China for the time being. It has plans to expand its non-gaming hospitality offer into mainland China and it needs Ms Ho’s political clout on the mainland to assist with that. Equally, Ms Ho should benefit from her closeness to the global leisure brand when she’s scouting for new business opportunities in the People’s Republic. But the non-compete agreement offers potential traps in MGM Resorts’ home markets. Those traps are not so much in its core market of Las Vegas—the company owns too much of the gaming real estate on the Las Vegas Strip ever to be put under any serious regulatory pressure by the Nevada authorities. But it could face awkward regulatory questions in its smaller US markets such as Michigan. MGM Resorts’ predecessor company MGM MIRAGE was forced to announce a pull out from its joint venture with Boyd Gaming in Atlantic City because the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement was unhappy about it even being connected with Pansy Ho.

MGM Resorts’ non-compete agreement with Ms Ho presupposes she will be a person of influence at STDM, even if technically she’s only a minority shareholder there. That means she will be expected to wield that influence either passively—by leaving the room or abstaining when a piece of STDM business relevant to MGM China’s interests is discussed—or to wield the influence actively, by seeking to steer STDM, SJM or Shun Tak away from a course of action that might hurt MGM China’s interests. The latter is explicitly mentioned in the agreement.

So Ms Ho has either to wield influence at STDM to make MGM Resorts happy—in which case she risks upsetting the  rest of the Macau market operators and possibly also her fellow directors at STDM—or she will have to choose between MGM China or STDM. Some think it would be better for the proper functioning of the market if she were forced to choose between the two now.

Let them eat cake

But where’s the incentive if she can have her cake and eat it? Ms Ho is certainly dining handsomely on the MGM Macau part of the cake. Her sale of 21% of MGM China Holdings in a Hong Kong flotation in late May (she previously held 50% of the joint venture) was expected to net her US$1.21 billion to US$1.5 billion cash, giving her a net worth of about US$5.1 billion and overnight making her Hong Kong’s richest woman.

Is an attack on her non-compete deal with MGM Resorts merely envy at her success? Does it matter if she’s a shareholder and director of two Macau gaming operators if she only holds a minority stake in each? They’re all good questions, and find echoes in anticompetitive practices that have been enthusiastically pursued for years in Hong Kong, where specifically, price-fixing for many goods and services abound.

Inside Asian Gaming makes no suggestion that price-fixing is the aim of the MGM Resorts non-compete agreement. But here’s why a non-compete agreement might cause problems for Macau. Macau depends for its international credibility as a gaming investment market on the notion that over time its regulatory and legal standards are converging with international standards, not diverging from them. North America and the European Union have outlawed most forms of anti-competitive agreement—as well as their ugly big sister, price-fixing cartels. It could therefore make overseas gaming regulators distinctly uncomfortable—and possibly harm Macau investors’ interests directly or indirectly—were the Macau government to encourage, or simply allow by default, an anti-competitive climate and anti-competitive practices to develop in relation to the local casino market.

RelatedPosts

MGM Resorts names talent agent Ryan Abboushi as President of Entertainment

MGM Resorts names talent agent Ryan Abboushi as President of Entertainment

Tue 13 May 2025 at 05:18
The show must go on

Fitch: Not implausible to see US operators forced to sell Macau casino interests should US-China relations deteriorate further

Fri 25 Apr 2025 at 06:26
The Japan IR Industry: A Golden Opportunity Squandered

MGM-Orix consortium breaks ground on Osaka IR project

Fri 25 Apr 2025 at 05:50

MGM Resorts to pay US$8.5 million to settle NGCB complaint over actions of illegal bookmakers at Vegas resorts

Sun 20 Apr 2025 at 07:59
Load More
Tags: MGM Resorts InternationalPansy Ho
ShareShare
Newsdesk

Newsdesk

The IAG Newsdesk team comprises some of the most experienced journalists in the Asian gaming industry. Offering a broad range of expertise, their decades of combined know-how spans multiple countries across a variety of topics.

Current Issue

Editorial – An inconvenient truth

Editorial – An inconvenient truth

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 15:21

It’s understandable that political observers, academics and members of the public in greenfield jurisdictions would express caution around the legalization...

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 15:19

Siobhan Lane, Light & Wonder’s highly experienced CEO of Gaming, speaks to Inside Asian Gaming about the company’s ongoing transformation...

Honesty is the best policy

Honesty is the best policy

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 14:13

The Thailand Entertainment Complex Roundtable brought industry stakeholders, politicians and supporters of the government’s Entertainment Complex Bill face to face...

Sri Lanka’s casino industry

Sri Lanka’s casino industry

by Shaun McCamley
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 13:36

Industry veteran Shaun McCamley delves into the complex history of Sri Lanka’s casino industry at a time when the country...

Evolution Asia
Your browser does not support HTML5 video.
Aristocrat
GLI
Nustar
SABA
Mindslot
Solaire
Hann
Tecnet
NWR
Jumbo
568Win

Related Posts

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

Light & Wonder’s Siobhan Lane

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 15:19

Siobhan Lane, Light & Wonder’s highly experienced CEO of Gaming, speaks to Inside Asian Gaming about the company’s ongoing transformation into a content powerhouse and reveals where Asia fits into the journey. Ben Blaschke: Thanks for speaking with IAG, Siobhan....

Behind the curtain

Behind the curtain

by Newsdesk
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 12:40

Hospitality logistics firm BCI Worldwide has firmly established its presence in Macau, playing a part in some of the city’s most iconic integrated resort development projects. Macau, the “Las Vegas of Asia”, is a city synonymous with opulent resorts, world-class...

Of fortune or misfortune

Of fortune or misfortune

by Pierce Chan
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 12:32

At the beginning of June, the Macau government announced that all 11 of the city’s satellite casinos would be shut down this year. The sudden news shocked the community and has led many to question whether the complete closure of...

10 years ago – Tricky balance

10 years ago – Tricky balance

by Ben Blaschke
Fri 27 Jun 2025 at 12:17

In this regular feature in IAG to celebrate 20 years covering the Asian gaming and leisure industry, we look back at our cover story from exactly 10 years ago, “Tricky balance”, to rediscover what was making the news in July...



IAG

© 2005-2024
Inside Asian Gaming.
All rights reserved.

  • SUBSCRIBE FREE
  • NEWSFEED
  • MAG ARTICLES
  • VIDEO
  • OPINION
  • TAGS
  • REGIONAL
  • EVENTS
  • CONSULTING
  • CONTRIBUTORS
  • MAGAZINES
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISE

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe
  • Newsfeed
  • Mag Articles
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Tags
  • Regional
  • Events
  • Contributors
  • Magazines
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • About
  • Home for G2E Asia

© 2005-2024
Inside Asian Gaming.
All rights reserved.

  • English